Security Analysis

Security Analysis

Share this post

Security Analysis
Security Analysis
2023: Performance & Activity Update
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

2023: Performance & Activity Update

Value Stock Geek's avatar
Value Stock Geek
Jan 03, 2024
∙ Paid
15

Share this post

Security Analysis
Security Analysis
2023: Performance & Activity Update
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Share

Happy New Year clipart
Photo by Sincerely Media on Unsplash

Performance

As of the end of 2023, my active account tracked on this substack showed a gain of 27.46%. In comparison, global stocks, represented by the VT ETF, closed the year with a 22.02% increase, while the S&P 500, tracked by the SPY ETF, recorded a total return of 26.19%.

Last year, I lost 13.52%, also slightly outperforming the VT and SPY benchmarks, which incurred losses of 18.01% and 18.17%, respectively.

Over the past couple of years, my performance has slightly exceeded those benchmarks.

Despite receiving some criticism for my choice of benchmarks, I think that VT and SPY are fine. I tend to deal in large caps (that’s where the best moats are), and that’s what those indexes represent.

I am not sure if there is a decent benchmark for a portfolio of 13 high-quality companies acquired at attractive valuations combined with an asset allocation strategy that uses real estate, small cap value, international small caps, gold, and long-term treasuries.

For a total look, here is how various asset classes and portfolios performed last year. The ‘weird portfolio’ is my asset allocation that I use instead of holding cash.

Macro

A year ago, this is what I wrote about the macro situation:

Heavy questions weigh on investors’ minds. Will the Fed be able to defeat inflation? Will the aggressive tightening result in a recession this year? How deep & lasting will the recession become, and how will the markets respond to it? Will the Fed continue tightening? Will the Fed cause a terrible deflationary recession, and will they go back to ZIRP and aggressive easing to fight it? Will the Fed engineer a soft landing where inflation eases and the economy keeps roaring, as Greenspan did in 1995, and led him to be declared a maestro?

If you’re expecting answers to these questions, you’re reading the wrong substack.

A year later, it appears that the Federal Reserve has successfully managed to curb inflation, or at least pushed it back a notch. Their tightening measures did not lead to a recession and inflation has retreated from 8.3% in 2022 to a more manageable 3.1%. This unexpected turn of events was the driving force behind the frenzy in the stock market.

This outcome has defied the expectations of many. Conversations with individuals a year ago predominantly fell into two camps: 1) those anticipating a recession with the Fed eventually resorting to Zero Interest Rate Policy (ZIRP), and 2) those predicting uncontrollable inflation with rising interest rates.

Anyone forecasting a soft landing likely would have faced considerable skepticism, but that’s what happened. Bulls always sound naive and bears always sound smart.

Meanwhile, 2020-21 looked like a speculative frenzy which fell apart in 2022. Most people I talk to thought that 2022 was something like 2000, the beginning of the end for a speculative cycle. I agreed with them.

Instead, with the renewed bull market, the speculative frenzy kicked back into high gear. Among aggressive investors, QQQ rallied nearly 55% after falling 32.58% in 2022. Among even more aggressive investors, ARKK increased 69% after falling 67% in 2022.

The gains from the past year were predominantly centered around the leading technology stocks. The enthusiasm surrounding artificial intelligence translated into remarkable gains, with Nvidia witnessing an astonishing 239% surge.

On the flip side, adopting an equal-weighted approach to the S&P 500—typically mirroring the broader index movements—yielded a more modest 9.68% gain, trailing the overall index's robust 26% increase.

Investors are now grappling with the looming question of whether the party will persist and if the tech sector can continue the gains witnessed in 2023. There's also a concern that the anticipated recession, which failed to materialize in 2023, might happen in 2024, potentially leading to a significant downturn in stocks.

As is customary, investors find themselves wrestling with the classic dilemma of FOMO (Fear of Missing Out) vs. the fear of losses, a struggle often influenced by their personalities.

My position? I don’t know.

My strategy involves pinpointing high-quality businesses that can perform well across an entire economic cycle.

The purpose of this substack is to identify these businesses by investigating a company ever single week. Often, the companies are too expensive when I first look at them. My goal is to acquire these companies when they face temporary setbacks and are available at attractive valuations. I sell if the business seems impaired or if its valuation is stretched. I don't even try to predict macroeconomic conditions.

Security Analysis is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

In simpler terms, I expect a severe recession to kick my ass eventually, but I don't believe I can accurately forecast when it will occur. To survive these events, I invest in businesses that exhibited resilience in the face of past recessions, have low debt, resilient cash flows, and possess an economic moat.

Additionally, I steer clear of investing in stocks with bubbly valuations, as these often suffer the most during bear markets. The leaders of a bull market are often led to the guillotine during the next bear.

I’ve tried the game of macro prediction and have utterly failed at it, so I don’t do that anymore. This is a lesson you learn with experience and you either wind up admitting it’s unpredictable or you develop a deep seated hatred of the Federal Reserve.

I believe this approach can deliver strong performance over the long term without the need for a crystal ball or advanced trading skills. After all, I don’t have a crystal ball or advanced trading skills. I don’t think anyone else does, either, but that’s another topic for another time.

Q4 Trades

In the past quarter, I executed the following trades:

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Value Stock Geek
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More